Difference Between Prim's and Kruskal's Algorithms
💡 Concept Name
Prim's vs Kruskal's Algorithm – Both are greedy strategies to find a Minimum Spanning Tree (MST) in a weighted graph, differing mainly in their process and data structures used.
📘 Quick Intro
Prim's algorithm starts with a single vertex and gradually adds the smallest edge connecting the growing MST to the remaining vertices. Kruskal's algorithm treats all edges sorted by weight, adding them one by one while avoiding cycles using union-find.
🧐 Analogy / Short Story
Think of Prim's like building a road network outwards from one city, expanding step-by-step. Kruskal’s is like always choosing the cheapest road anywhere on the map, provided it doesn't create loops.
🔧 Technical Explanation
- 🔄 Approach: Prim's expands MST from a starting node; Kruskal's sorts edges and adds them if they don’t form cycles.
- ⏳ Time Complexity: Prim’s with min-heap: O(E + log V), Kruskal’s: O(E log E) due to sorting and union-find.
- 🪧 Data Structure: Prim uses priority queues; Kruskal uses Disjoint Set Union (Union-Find).
- 💼 Use Case: Prim is preferable for dense graphs; Kruskal suits sparse graphs.
- 📃 Graph Type: Both algorithms work on connected, weighted, undirected graphs.
🌟 Purpose & Use Case
- ✅ Designing efficient network cabling or road layouts.
- ✅ Circuit design for minimizing wiring cost.
- ✅ Cluster analysis in data mining (often Kruskal’s).
💻 Real Code Example
// Simplified Kruskal's MST implementation in C#
class Edge
{
public int Src, Dest, Weight;
}
class Subset { public int Parent, Rank; }
int Find(Subset[] subsets, int i)
{
if (subsets[i].Parent != i)
subsets[i].Parent = Find(subsets, subsets[i].Parent);
return subsets[i].Parent;
}
void Union(Subset[] subsets, int x, int y)
{
int xroot = Find(subsets, x);
int yroot = Find(subsets, y);
if (subsets[xroot].Rank < subsets[yroot].Rank)
subsets[xroot].Parent = yroot;
else if (subsets[xroot].Rank > subsets[yroot].Rank)
subsets[yroot].Parent = xroot;
else {
subsets[yroot].Parent = xroot;
subsets[xroot].Rank++;
}
}
❓ Interview Q&A
Q1: What problem do Prim's and Kruskal's algorithms solve?
A: Finding the Minimum Spanning Tree (MST) of a connected, weighted graph.
Q2: How does Prim's algorithm work?
A: It starts from a single vertex and grows the MST by adding the cheapest edge connecting the tree to a new vertex.
Q3: How does Kruskal's algorithm work?
A: It sorts all edges by weight and adds them one by one, avoiding cycles, until the MST is formed.
Q4: Which data structure is commonly used in Kruskal's algorithm to detect cycles?
A: Disjoint Set Union (Union-Find).
Q5: Which algorithm is better for dense graphs?
A: Prim's algorithm, especially with adjacency matrix representation.
Q6: Which algorithm is better for sparse graphs?
A: Kruskal's algorithm.
Q7: Does Prim's algorithm always start from the same vertex?
A: It can start from any vertex.
Q8: What is the time complexity of Prim's algorithm using a min-heap?
A: O(E log V), where E is edges and V is vertices.
Q9: What is the time complexity of Kruskal's algorithm?
A: O(E log E) due to edge sorting.
Q10: Can both algorithms produce the same MST?
A: Yes, they both produce a valid MST, though the order of edges may differ.
📝 MCQs
Q1. What problem do Prim's and Kruskal's algorithms solve?
- Shortest Path
- Minimum Spanning Tree
- Maximum Flow
- Cycle Detection
Q2. How does Prim's algorithm build the MST?
- Sorting edges
- Starting from a vertex, adding cheapest edges
- Random edges
- DFS traversal
Q3. How does Kruskal's algorithm build the MST?
- Adding edges randomly
- Adding edges in ascending order avoiding cycles
- DFS traversal
- Using adjacency matrix
Q4. Which data structure helps Kruskal detect cycles?
- Heap
- Queue
- Disjoint Set Union
- Stack
Q5. Which algorithm is better for dense graphs?
- Kruskal's algorithm
- Prim's algorithm
- DFS
- BFS
Q6. Which algorithm is better for sparse graphs?
- Prim's algorithm
- Kruskal's algorithm
- DFS
- BFS
Q7. What is the time complexity of Prim's algorithm?
- O(V^2)
- O(E log V)
- O(E^2)
- O(V log E)
Q8. What is the time complexity of Kruskal's algorithm?
- O(V^2)
- O(E log E)
- O(E^2)
- O(V log E)
Q9. Can both algorithms produce the same MST?
- No
- Yes
- Sometimes
- Only for trees
Q10. Does Prim's algorithm need a starting vertex?
- No
- Yes, any vertex
- Only vertex 0
- Random vertex
💡 Bonus Insight
Choosing between Prim’s and Kruskal’s often depends on graph density and data structure availability. Optimized implementations of Prim’s use Fibonacci heaps for improved performance on dense graphs.
📄 PDF Download
Need a handy summary for your notes? Download this topic as a PDF!